World

Can desperate Europe, UK think out of the box as migrants swamp continent?

European countries have tied themselves up in knots over trying to keep migrants out.

The European Union (EU) signed a “strategic and comprehensive partnership” agreement with north African nation Tunisia last week in which it will give $1.1 billion as aid in return for Tunisia tightening its borders and battling migration to Europe. The deal is supposed to provide climate change help as well as stabilise economy in the country.

Tunisia is a major route for migrants and refugees planning to travel to EU nations. The deal takes place at a time when Europe is facing record migration levels as well as boat drownings that are killing hundreds of people at sea.

 

The architects of the agreement are President Ursula Von der Leyen, Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte, and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who travelled earlier this month to Tunisia to discuss the deal with Tunisian President Kais Saied.

President Saied is leading a nation that is on the verge of an economic collapse, waiting for a bailout from international institutions. The 2011 revolution upstaged the economy, followed by militant attacks in 2015, the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020 and drought.

Even as Leyen, Rutte and Meloni trumpet their deal as a path-breaker for European nations to tackle the flow of migrants into their countries, it has been criticised by human rights organisations. The agreement has come under fire for its support to President Saied who has allegedly fostered a non-democratic environment in his country. The deal is also being condemned for blocking routes to migrants and denying asylum-seekers the right to scout for refuge.

The UK too has been jumping from one possible solution to another possible solution to stem the tide of boat landings and illegal immigrants flowing into the country. Most of those ideas have been rubbished by human rights advocates.

The government has estimated that nearly 45,000 people arrived in 1,053 small boats in the UK in just one year.

In one of its latest actions to hold the asylum seekers, the British government has rented out a huge engineless barge, called Bibby Stockholm,  where it plans to accommodate 500 men seeking asylum in the UK. Applications for asylum will be processed while the men stay on the barge.

The barge has been towed to Portland Port in Dorset and has been retrofitted as a hotel with cabins, en-suite bathrooms, bunk-beds, corridors, common areas, prayer rooms, dining rooms, a gym and other spaces.

The barge, which has facilities for food as well as health, has often been compared to a floating prison. Besides inviting disapproval from various quarters over living conditions, cramped quarters and not treating vulnerable people with dignity, the local residents too are not enthusiastic about so many men being too close for comfort.

The barge scheme is the second controversial policy by the British government to manage migrants. The earlier one – flying off asylum seekers to Rwanda in central-east Africa, was struck down by a British court as unlawful. In June this year, the court said that Rwanda could not be considered a safe third country for migrants to be deported from the UK.

Britain’s Rwandan policy has been met with opprobrium right from the start, when former prime minister Boris Johnson had ushered in the idea.

The court even said that there existed a high possibility that the asylum seekers might be deported to their own countries from Rwanda where they might face persecution.

Europe and the UK have been battling, rather unsuccessfully, migration as well as assimilation issues as refugees stream into Europe from conflict and poverty-ridden zones in Africa and Asia. The end of the Afghan war in 2021 exacerbated the crisis as Afghans, fearful of Taliban vengeance, fled across the world, as far as Brazil, US and Canada.

Rahul Kumar

Rahul Kumar writes on international issues and is a keen watcher of South Asia, environment, urban development and NGOs.

Recent Posts

VINBAX 2024: Vietnam-India bilateral army exercise concludes at Kaushalya Dam

The fifth edition of the historic Indo-Vietnam Joint Field Training Exercise, VINBAX-2024, successfully concluded its…

15 hours ago

India-Russia strengthen defence ties at 22nd Working Group meeting on military technical cooperation

The 22nd meeting of the India-Russia Working Group on Military technical cooperation and defence industry…

15 hours ago

“I want to have strong representation of India at World Nuclear Exhibition 2025”: Sylvie Bermann

Sylvie Bermann, President of the World Nuclear Exhibition expressed confidence in India's nuclear supply chain…

16 hours ago

PoJK: Joint Awami Action Committee protests against government following new ordinance, many injured

Joint Awami Action Committee core member Shaukat Nawaz Mir has condemned the attack of police…

17 hours ago

PM Modi meets 31 world leaders, heads of organisations during his 3-nation foreign visit

Prime Minister Narendra Modi participated in 31 Bilateral Meetings and informal interactions with global leaders…

19 hours ago

India- Australia conduct 11th Indian Air Force-Royal Australian Air Force Air Staff Talks

India and Australia conducted the 11th edition of the Indian Air Force and Royal Australian…

19 hours ago